Winking Isle
From The Fifth City Wiki

A desolate speck of rock in the middle of, well, nowhere.
The only visitor to this island spent quite a bit of time fasting and meditating with Mr. Eaten. He offered his most prized possessions in sacrifice. He stayed long enough to obtain some of Mr. Eaten's elusive candles. But he didn't have time to pass on Mr. Eaten's calling card - your ticket to Winking Isle - to another player, as this was just before the Seeking Mr. Eaten's Name storyline was frozen.
Further details about the Isle, from its sole visitor, are below.
http://nightmarethrenody.tumblr.com/post/69675861656/when-mr-eaten-comes-a-calling